Happy Birthday Charles Ives

Charles Ives was an American Romantic/modern composer born in Danbury, CT on October 20, 1874. He lived 79 years – died on May 19, 1954 in New York City.

Charles Ives [1874 -1954]

To recognize this great American composer on his birthday, I’d like to do this post I published a couple of years ago entitled: “Charles Ives Composes the First American Symphony”.

Charles Ives Composes the First ‘American Symphony’ [post published originally on another blog I had in 2019]:

One of the things I love most about going to the Houston Symphony Orchestra’s concerts at Jones Hall is their pre-concert talks they generously give before each concert called ‘prelude’.

The fetching Mrs. B and I have learned so much from these talks about the great composers and their music.  There have been many great lovers and teachers of classical music giving these talks, but none better than the man giving the prelude talks this concert season, The Houston Symphony’s musical Ambassador and assistant conductor, Carlos Andres Botero.  This man is so positive, enthusiastic, friendly and informative with his obvious love of the music and the composers, that it is conveyed to all those attending the pre-concert talks.  You can tell that by the smile on everyone’s face in attendance during his lectures.

Maestro Carlos Andres Botero

This ‘prelude’ talk on October 17, 2015, Maestro Botero talked about American composer Charles Ives and his Symphony #2 that we were about to hear on the first half of the concert.  

Maestro Botero related that up until Charles Ives lifetime classical music from American composers was considered inferior to the music that was composed from the great masters of Europe.  

So, the American composers mostly followed the ideas and sounds from the great composers of Europe.  For the most part they didn’t develop an American symphonic sound, an American symphony as such. 

It actually took the Czech composer, Antonin Dvorak, using folk songs, Native American music, and old Negro spirituals, that he learned from his visit to the United States from 1892-1895, to compose his “New World Symphony” #9 in the late 19th century.

Charles Ives in his first symphony followed the German Romantic model of Brahms and others in his first symphony.  He would quote ideas from Bach, Beethoven, Brahms and Dvorak in this composition. 

But Ives was a great patriotic American and did want to compose an American symphony that would show his pride of America, and show that an American composer could compose an American symphony not inferior to the great masters of the West. He did this in his second Symphony he composed sometime between 1897-1902 [and it took 50 years to be performed in its entirety before a concert audience].  

While for the most part Ives still followed the Brahms German Romantic model in this symphony, what he did to make this an American symphony was that he weaved into this symphony brief  moments of American folk tunes, religious hymns, gospel music, etc.  In fact there were 15 different “American tunes” that he gave quick glimpses of in this symphony.  Carlos Andres Botero gave a great analogy saying that it was like if you were listening to classical music in your car and somebody came along in another car with music blasting of some other music [rap, or country, or pop] and while it passed your car you would get a brief sound of that other music weaved into the classical music you were listening to; and then that sound would quickly go away, and you would only hear the classical music, as the other car left.  

In his talk, Carlos Botero gave audio examples of first some of the American tunes [like hymns, etc. as they would be sung] then of the brief moment that it sounded like in Ives symphony.  While I didn’t recognize some of the religious hymns, I knew my wife did because I could hear her humming as the music was playing.  Mr. Botero then played songs everyone knew, like “Camptown races” and “America the Beautiful” briefly quoted in the symphony and everyone laughed when they heard “Turkey in the Straw”.  Maestro Botero, in his pleasant Colombian-American accent then asked if we [the patrons in attendance at the prelude talk] could help him with the pronunciation of a song that he played for us, also included briefly included in Ives Second Symphony.  That American song was…reveille.  🙂 

To make sure everyone knew this “American Symphony’ was not just any symphony, Ives ended it in a surprising dissonant chord that you probably have never heard to end a symphony.  This was his punctuation mark to emphasize that this was a different symphony-the first American symphony composed by an American composer. 

The symphony does not have a specific key as each movement is in a different key. There are five movements in Ives Symphony #2:  1. Andante moderato,  2. Allegro,  3. Adagio Cantabile,  4. Lento maestoso and 5. Allegro molto vivace.  

Remember you must listen closely as some of the hymns or other American tunes or quoted very briefly and sometimes in variation of the original theme.  You should have no trouble hearing reveille near the end of this American Symphony that I bet will make you smile.  

Please turn up the volume to enjoy the first American symphony composed by an American composer-Charles Ives.  

Charles Ives: Symphony #2, American:


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s